Wednesday, July 24, 2024

JUDGE GREENLIGHTS EUTHANASIA FOR 27 YEAR OLD AUTISTIC WOMAN DESPITE OBJECTIONS FROM FATHER

Here’s another article on Canada’s culture of death:

 

Alberta judge greenlights euthanasia for 27-year-old autistic woman DESPITE objections from her dad, who says she's healthy - just 'vulnerable' due to mental health problems

The father and daughter live together, but disagree about her suicide request

Justice Colin Feasby says her right to die trumps the dad's love for his daughter

By JAMES REINL, SOCIAL AFFAIRS CORRESPONDENT, FOR DAILYMAIL.COM

PUBLISHED: 10:39 EDT, 27 March 2024 | UPDATED: 10:40 EDT, 27 March 2024

 

A judge in Canada has cleared the way for a 27-year-old autistic woman to be euthanized despite objections from her dad, who says she's 'healthy' — just 'vulnerable' due to her mental health problems.

 

In his ruling, Justice Colin Feasby acknowledged that the doctor-assisted death would cause the father 'profound grief,' but said the young woman's right to end her own life trumped his feelings.

 

A publication ban protects the identities of the dad, the daughter, and her doctors. The father is referred to as WV, and she as MV.

 

'MV's dignity and right to self-determination outweighs the important matters raised by WV and the harm that he will suffer in losing MV,' Feasby wrote in his 34-page ruling, which was issued this week.

 

'Though I find that WV has raised serious issues, I conclude that MV's autonomy and dignity interests outweigh competing considerations.'

 

The Calgary judge's decision will be paused for 30 days, so the dad's lawyers have a chance to appeal.

 

The case spotlights Canada's euthanasia system, known as medical assistance in dying (MAiD), which has grown rapidly since it was introduced in 2016, with more than 13,000 people being euthanized each year.

 

MV lives with her father and was approved for euthanasia in December.

 

She did not file any court documents explaining how she came to qualify for MAiD, according to Canadian news outlets.

 

Her lawyer, Austin Paladeau, said the case boils down to the daughter's right to autonomy and that the dad's affection for his daughter 'does not give him the right to keep her alive against her wishes.'

 

But WV says his daughter 'is vulnerable and is not competent to make the decision to take her own life,' the judge wrote.

 

'He says that she is generally healthy and believes that her physical symptoms, to the extent that she has any, result from undiagnosed psychological conditions.'

 

Her only known diagnoses described at a previous hearing earlier were autism and hyperactivity disorder.

 

The dad's lawyers had asked for a judicial review to examine how the daughter got MAID approval.

 

Under Canada's euthanasia system, two doctors or nurse practitioners have to greenlight a patient for MAiD.

 

When MV applied to Alberta Health Services for an assisted death, she was apprved by one doctor and rejected by another.

 

A third 'tie-breaker' doctor then approved the procedure.

 

WV questioned the third doctor's sign-off, saying he 'was not independent or objective.'

 

In his ruling, Feasby said the young woman had 'struggled to find a doctor who could diagnose [her] condition and offer appropriate treatment.'

 

'I do not know why you seek MAID,' the judge wrote.

 

'Your reasons remain your own because I have respected your autonomy and your privacy.

 

'My decision recognizes your right to choose medically assisted death; but it does not require you to choose death.'

 

Without MAiD, the woman would have to choose between living a life she saw as intolerable and suicide, he said.

 

Any adult in Canada with a serious illness, disease, or disability can seek help in dying

 

'This is a terrible choice that should not be forced on MV, as attempting to end her life without medical assistance would put her at increased risk of pain, suffering and lasting injury,' he wrote.

 

Even so, the daughter's death would leave the parents 'devastated,' added the judge.

 

'For many parents, the loss of a child is a life-changing event that they never truly recover from,' he wrote.

 

'The loss is immeasurable.'

 

The dad's lawyer Sarah Miller said it was not clear if they would appeal the ruling and push for a judicial review of the case.

 

The father-daughter row is the latest controversy to spotlight one of the world's most permissive assisted-dying programs.

 

Alex Schadenberg, who leads the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition campaign group, said it showcased the problems with MAiD.

 

'Canada's euthanasia law was not designed to protect vulnerable people,' Schadenberg said.

 

'The law is designed to protect the doctors who are willing to kill.'

 

Many Canadians support euthanasia and the campaign group, Dying With Dignity, says procedures are 'driven by compassion, an end to suffering and discrimination and desire for personal autonomy.'

 

Canada has among the highest rates of assisted dying in the world

 

Rights groups say the country's regulations lack necessary safeguards, devalue the lives of disabled people, and prompt doctors and health workers to suggest the procedure to those who might not otherwise consider it.

 

The number of MAiD deaths jumped 31.2 percent to 13,241 between 2021 and 2022, official numbers show.

 

Some 44,958 people have received assisted deaths since the federal MAiD law was introduced in 2016.

 

Canada's road to allowing euthanasia began in 2015, when its top court declared that outlawing assisted suicide deprived people of their dignity and autonomy. It gave national leaders a year to draft legislation.

 

The resulting 2016 law legalized both euthanasia and assisted suicide for people aged 18 and over, provided they met certain conditions:

 

They had to have a serious, advanced condition, disease, or disability that was causing suffering and their death was looming.

 

The law was later amended to allow people who are not terminally ill to choose death, significantly broadening the number of eligible people.

 

Under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's liberal government, Canada has repeatedly made it easier to access euthanasia

 

The number of MAiD deaths in Canada has risen steadily by about a third each year

 

Critics say that change removed a key safeguard aimed at protecting people with potentially decades of life left.

 

Today, any adult with a serious illness, disease, or disability can seek help in dying.

 

Officials in February delayed plans to expand MAiD access to those with mental illnesses, kicking a decision back to 2027.

 

There are also efforts to make euthanasia available to 'mature minors.'

 

Euthanasia is legal in seven countries — Belgium, Canada, Colombia, Luxembourg, Netherlands, New Zealand and Spain — plus several states in Australia.

 

Other jurisdictions, including a growing number of US states, allow doctor-assisted suicide — in which patients take the drug themselves, typically crushing up and drinking a lethal dose of pills prescribed by a physician.

 

In Canada, both options are referred to as MAiD, though more than 99.9 percent of such procedures are carried out by a doctor. The number of MAiD deaths in Canada has risen steadily by about a third each year.

CANADA'S PERMISSIVE EUTHANASIA LAWS SPARK DEBATE ON THE TRUE MEANING OF DISABILITY

From a social justice warrior, but still.

 

FORBES

 

Canada’s Permissive Euthanasia Laws Spark Debate On The True Meaning Of Disability

Gus Alexiou

Contributor

I write about accessibility, inclusion and social justice.

 

During the past few days, organizations representing people with disabilities in Canada have spoken out vociferously against the country’s ultra-liberal laws on assisted dying – identifying them as an existential threat to those they represent.

 

Canada’s medical assistance in dying (MAID) laws, established in 2016, received global media scrutiny last year in the wake of several high-profile cases.

 

Opponents continue to express distaste and discomfort with physicians routinely and all too casually setting out options around assisted dying alongside other medical interventions, not just for the terminally Ill, but for patients with chronic conditions with the potential to yet enjoy many more fulfilling years ahead with the appropriate support.

 

Though last month, the Liberal government rowed back on plans to immediately extend medically assisted dying provisions to individuals living with a range of mental health conditions, it is widely accepted that this is simply a hiatus during which the appropriate protocols will be finalized before the policy is rolled out.

 

On January 5, an open letter jointly penned by multiple disability groups opposing MAiD in Canada was sent to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Justice Minister David Lametti and Leader of the Opposition Pierre Poilievre amongst other important stakeholders.

 

The letter was unequivocal in its opening statement:

 

“We, the undersigned disability and human rights organizations are writing to express our concern and opposition to the legalization of Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD) for mental illness and to the already-legal practise of euthanizing people with disabilities who are not terminally ill.”

 

The debate around euthanasia is quite different from any other debate around accessibility – notwithstanding the profound moral complexities in which it will forever be entangled.

 

In most discourse on disability rights – access to goods, services and civic participation is universally heralded as a positive thing.

 

In these contexts, there is no such thing as “too much accessibility.” Even in situations where accessibility is inadequate, the vast majority acknowledge it to be a noble aspiration, too often compromised by financial resources and competing priorities.

 

In assisted dying, both ferocious opponents and advocates project themselves as the self-appointed champions of the disability community.

 

Proponents claim they are sparing seriously ill people from unbearable pain and suffering by promoting self-determination, stripping back centuries of outmoded and irrelevant religious precepts.

 

Opponents, on the other hand, say that the casual proliferation and over- liberalization of medical assistance in dying devalues the divergent but meaningful lived experience of disabled people and provides the state with an easy way of foregoing its responsibilities to its most vulnerable citizens.

 

Cutting across this is a discourse around the decades-long, but yet, incomplete evolution from the medical to the social model of disability.

 

The former expounds that disability is a matter purely centered around deficits of the affected person’s physiology.

 

Where these cannot be satisfactorily addressed therapeutically – it might be reasonable to consider an alternative medical means of ending pain and suffering.

 

The social model, on the other hand, is far more layered and nuanced and views the negative experiences of many disabled people as the product of entirely optional social constructs in addition to physical impairments.

 

After all, poor access to public transportation and employment, discriminatory public attitudes and media projections and a paucity of welfare benefits that force many disabled people, even those living in wealthy countries, to live on the breadline, are not inevitable results of any one illness or disease.

 

These are active choices, usually made by non-disabled people at all levels of society, to behave in a certain way towards people with disabilities, or simply look the other way and not consider them at all.

 

Consequently, the recent missive penned by Canada’s disability rights collective stated:

 

“We know, as do you, that the existing law is not working and has not worked, and that people with disabilities have been dying by MAiD due to their life circumstances and oppression.”

 

Later adding, “As a country, we cannot provide state-assisted death to people who are not terminally ill, without ensuring a legislated right to a decent life for all. The current MAiD law has chipped away at the constitutional protections of Canadians. The very existence of the current law is a threat to the lives of people with disabilities and their families.”

 

Running out of choices

 

Dr. Stefanie Green is a physician who has assisted over 300 patients to die and is the author of This Is Assisted Dying: A Doctor's Story of Empowering Patients at the End of Life. She also heads up the Canadian Association of MAID Assessors and Providers (CAMAP).

 

Dr. Green, in a recent interview given to The New Atlantis stated, “You cannot access MAID in this country because you can’t get housing. That is clickbait. These stories have not been reported fully,”

 

Yet, Alexander Raikin, the author of The New Atlantis article also cited a stash of verified CAMAP training materials in which specific guidance is given on how to weigh up and assess patient-reported poverty and economic deprivation.

 

In 2023, and concerning Canada’s unique pedal-to-the-metal approach to assisted dying in particular – there remain many more questions than entirely satisfactory answers.

 

Even though it continues to be unlawful in most parts of the world, many western societies at least acknowledge that judiciously administered and highly controlled medically assisted dying is certainly no outrage in a fair-minded egalitarian society.

 

However, it is surely reasonable to suggest that its laissez-faire overuse underpinned by political ideology and a lack of sufficient safeguards is a far worse outcome than an outright ban.

 

It is a timely reminder to disability rights campaigners that their avowed mission of assisting people with disabilities to live dignified lives as integrated members of society did not peak out in the 1990s.

 

As societies evolve and modernize – new threats emerge and the hazards of staying silent can be now, more than ever, a matter of life and death.

 

Gus Alexiou

 

I am a journalist specializing in issues affecting people living with physical... Read More

FIRST TUESDAY MUSE AUGUST 6 7:00 P.M. AT FINN'S IN MADOC

Hello all, this is your two-week reminder of our next Open Mic!

Finn's Pub in Madoc - 7-9 pm

Cheers,

TJB 

Sunday, July 21, 2024

BOB NEWHART - TOBACO

Here’s a hilarious Bob Newhart skit about the introduction of tobacco to civilization. Enjoy.

 

Introducing Tobacco to Civilization (youtube.com) 

PHIL SPECTOR'S MURDER TRIALS: INSIDE THE PRODUCER'S INFAMOUS CRIME THAT ROCKED HOLLYWOOD IN2003

PEOPLE

 

Phil Spector's Murder Trials: Inside the Producer's Infamous Crime That Rocked Hollywood in 2003

Songwriter and producer Phil Spector was convicted of killing actress Lana Clarkson in his California home in 2003

By Emily Blackwood  Published on July 18, 2024 11:30AM EDT

 

Phil Spector was both a prolific producer and a convicted killer.

 

An icon in the music industry, Spector produced multiple hits for big-name artists like The Ronettes, The Beatles and Tina Turner. He developed a production formula called the “Wall of Sound” that eventually earned him a spot in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1989. So fans were shocked to see his name in tabloid headlines as a prime murder suspect decades later.

 

In 2009, the songwriter was found guilty of second-degree murder in the 2003 shooting death of Lana Clarkson. Spector met the 40-year-old actress, who starred in the 1985 cult film Barbarian Queen, on Feb. 3, 2003, at the House of Blues VIP room in West Hollywood, where she worked as a hostess.

 

The following morning, she was found dead in Spector's foyer with a gunshot wound to the mouth. The producer was quickly arrested and later charged with her murder.

 

Spector maintained his innocence, and his legal team claimed that Clarkson killed herself with his 38-caliber pistol because she was depressed over a breakup. While his first trial in September 2007 failed to reach a verdict, Spector was retried in October 2008 and found guilty. He was sentenced to 19 years to life in prison and died of COVID-related complications on Jan. 16, 2021, at the age of 80.

 

Most recently, his case was explored in the latest series of Netflix's Homicide: Los Angeles. Episode 1, titled "Hunting Phil Spector," revisits his fatal crime and the years-long prosecution against him.

 

Here's everything to know about Phil Spector's crime and lengthy murder trial.

 

Who was Phil Spector?

 

Spector started in the music industry at 17 when he wrote his first hit song, "To Know Him Is to Love Him," for the Teddy Bears. The tune sold 2.5 million copies, and four years later, Spector was running his own music company, Philles Records.

 

He is credited with revolutionizing the music industry with his "Wall of Sound," which blends layers of instruments and vocals. He was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame by Turner in 1989.

 

From 1968 to 1974, the producer was married to Ronettes front-woman Ronnie Spector, though the singer has alleged the relationship was abusive. “Phil’s abuse was mental, not physical; telling me how useless I am, and I’ll never sing again and I’ll never be successful again without him,” she recalled to PEOPLE in 2018. “All those things made me say, ‘You wanna bet?’ ”

Who did Phil Spector murder?

 

While she may have been a hostess the night she met Spector, Clarkson was a well-known working actress. According to the Los Angeles Times, she started modeling and acting as a teen after her father died in a mining accident. She played small parts in major '80s sitcoms like Night Court and Three's Company before landing the lead in action-packed sword and sorcery pictures like Barbarian Queen.

 

Though a wrist injury prevented her from performing for the last year of her life, the directors of the 2022 Showtime docuseries Spector maintained that Clarkson was more of an actress than tabloid headlines made her out to be.

 

“You couldn’t hear anything about this case without the tag ‘B-movie actress’ coming before ‘the victim, Lana Clarkson,’ ” Sheena M. Joyce, who directed the series with Don Argott, told the Los Angeles Times. “It was this little moniker that was another way to denigrate her. It creates a narrative of longing for the A-list and a desperation that would drive her to that house that night. The suggestion is that she was somehow asking for it or got what was coming to her.”

 

Her mom, Donna Clarkson, even told the outlet that her daughter was considering leaving the House of Blues job because it interfered with her auditions.

 

Why did Lana Clarkson go to Phil Spector’s house?

 

The night of the murder, Spector had been out with a female companion. In 2007, investigative journalist Dominick Dunne reported in Vanity Fair that the producer had been drinking and appeared to be "heavily medicated."

 

Clarkson reportedly didn't recognize him — and even mistakenly addressed him as "miss" — until a waitress named Sophia Holguin informed her that he was a very important man who tipped well.

 

After Spector had his driver take his female companion home, he asked Holguin to accompany him back to his residence in Alhambra, Calif., dubbed the Pyrenees Castle for its palace-like structure. She declined, so he asked Clarkson instead. She allegedly reluctantly agreed to go for one drink.

 

How did Phil Spector kill Lana Clarkson?

 

Around 5 a.m. on Feb. 3, 2003, Spector's driver called 911 after hearing a gunshot from inside the estate. The chauffeur claimed to see Spector come outside with a gun in his hand and say, “I think I just shot her.”

 

When police arrived, they found Clarkson dead in the foyer. They also uncovered a gun believed to be the murder weapon from the premises, and Spector was arrested on suspicion of murder around 6 a.m.

 

While Spector maintained his innocence and claimed Clarkson died by suicide, the Los Angeles County coroner ruled Clarkson's death a homicide on Sept. 22, 2003.

 

Prior to the murder, Spector had a reputation for waving firearms. He reportedly pulled out a pistol during a recording session with John Lennon (Spector produced 1971's Imagine), and Ramones bassist Dee Dee Ramone once accused the producer of doing the same during a 1980 session for End of the Century.

 

In 1998, his ex-wife Ronnie, who was suing him for back royalties, testified in court that "he threatened me many times with guns."

 

What happened during Phil Spector's murder trial?

 

Nine months after Clarkson was shot inside Spector's home, the record producer was charged with murder on Nov. 20, 2003.

 

Spector maintained his innocence throughout his first trial, which lasted over five months. After deliberating for 15 days, the jury remained deadlocked, with 10 jurors voting guilty and two voting not guilty. Because the decision needed to be unanimous, the judge declared a mistrial in September 2007.

 

The disgraced producer was retried the following year, and on April 13, 2009, a Los Angeles jury found Spector guilty of second-degree murder.

 

Spector was given the maximum sentence of 19 years to life in prison. He also had to pay Clarkson's mother $16,811 for funeral expenses, as well as $9,740 to a state restitution fund, among other fees, according to AP.

 

What happened to Phil Spector?

 

Following his 2009 murder conviction, Spector spent the rest of his life in prison. He died on Jan. 16, 2021, at age 80.

 

Though the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation released a statement confirming that Spector died of natural causes, his daughter, Nicole Audrey Spector, told The New York Times that his death was due to COVID-19 complications.

 

Upon his death, his ex-wife Ronnie wrote on Instagram that Spector had been "a brilliant producer but a lousy husband," per the BBC.

 

"Unfortunately, Phil was not able to live and function outside of the recording studio. Darkness set in, many lives were damaged," she wrote.